I am a professor waiting to be be approved by the means of peer review.

GeraldtheGnome
GeraldtheGnome: My name is Wolfgang Amadeus-Amadeus Rockme-Armadeus Orgoarn- Get-rooted Mozart. I am a Professor and I have finished my research where I am in support of the current effects of global warming. I put down that it is true that it is occurring right due to it being an established fact that global warming is occurring right now. I stressed why it is happening right now and that it is not caused by Humans. I sent my research off to be peer reviewed and published.

My name is Gretabon Zoneo Pubik Fur-in-daburger. I am a climate scientist living in Stockholm, I was born in Stockholmsyndomeberg, Sweden. I am a vegan, I ate fake Swedish Meatballs, I have Ikea furniture, I hug trees, sail around the world to climate conferences and have said, "How dare you !", to world leaders. After all they have stolen my hopes and my dreams. In the past they also did that when I should have been at school. I am a scientist with a mental disorder. We have to 'save the world' or impending doom will come soon. I made it clear that it is a well known fact that global warming is occurring right now and that humans have caused it. I sent my research off to be peer reviewed and published. I drive an electric car and I am for carbon taxes. I support Joe Biden and Black Lives Matter. I drink Bud Light.

My name is Joe Blow, I am considered to be an outcast scientist, I have to fund my own research, government funding was denied to me. I live like most people do and I eat meat. I fly and use transport in the way that most people do, I have a standard car. I have completed my findings on global warming and have stated the reason why there is no proof that global warming is occurring right now. I am wanting a peer review approval.

I am Doctor Uzininemillimetre Hasta La-Vista Baybee Freeze. I drive a Hummer, I use non-biodegradable styrofoam containers and eskies. I have have a toxic waste dump that I own, I dump things illegally. I own oil and gas companies that have had major environmental disasters. I am a Grand Wizard in the KKK, I'm for white power and Adolf Hitler. Global cooling is occurring and I am waiting for a peer review approval of my work.

These are all about fictional people of course. What if each of them are real people waiting for peer review right now ? How according to you will any of the examples go so far as a peer review is concerned ? How does a peer review work ? Is it dependent on one person giving approval to what has been presented or it is it due to more than two people approving it or is either one person or two more more people approving what is presented really what peer review is all about ?
(Edited by GeraldtheGnome)
8 months ago Report
0
Sir Loin
Sir Loin: Peer review is a load of shite, one person will select the reviewers and if s/he disagrees with the author will stack the reviewers with those hostile to the author's hypothesis. For this reason I refuse to submit anything for peer review. In any case I have no peers because I hold many unpopular views and it's impossible to find reviewers who can use critical thinking or even common sense.
Peer review is all about money, not truth in science. Going against the current narrative will not make money. Research grants come when one supports whatever narrative is in fashion that day. Take Anthropogenic Global Warming for example.
8 months ago Report
0
bonzono
(Post deleted by GeraldtheGnome 6 months ago)
bonzono
(Post deleted by GeraldtheGnome 6 months ago)
GeraldtheGnome
GeraldtheGnome: There are better suited words Sir Loin that you could have chosen. Why didn't you also just use she/he ? I also cannot understand why you don't use a space between paragraphs. Anyway the thing is that peer review is not the best way to go with anything to do with science, that of religion and that of politics. Confirmation bias, religious bias (in some cases) as well as in some cases religious like bias as well as any other bias is not guaranteed to be left out of anything that has been peer reviewed.
5 months ago Report
0
bonzono
(Post deleted by GeraldtheGnome 5 months ago)
bonzono
(Post deleted by GeraldtheGnome 5 months ago)
GeraldtheGnome
GeraldtheGnome: Anyway this obviously is a hypothetical scenario but anyway I am changing it slightly, this time it’s about me as Georges Prosper Remi, also known as Herge, at Tintin University in Belgium. I’m into peer reviewed science and I am for that Birds are Dinosaurs. I must be right because so many people agree with me without checking if they are right and without me checking that I am right.
(Edited by GeraldtheGnome)
4 months ago Report
0
bonzono
(Post deleted by GeraldtheGnome 4 months ago)